Strong leadership is the foundation of any successful law firm. However, leadership effectiveness is not solely determined by a partner’s experience or case outcomes—it’s also shaped by how they manage, mentor, and support associates. Upward reviews provide a structured way for law firms to gather feedback from associates about partners, offering valuable insights into leadership strengths and areas for improvement.
At Survey Research Associates (SRA), we help law firms implement upward review programs that strengthen relationships between partners and associates. By fostering a culture of open feedback, firms can enhance leadership effectiveness, improve workplace morale, and drive long-term success.
What Are Upward Reviews and Why Do They Matter?
Upward reviews are structured feedback processes where associates assess partners or senior attorneys on leadership skills, mentorship quality, and management effectiveness. Unlike traditional performance reviews, which focus on evaluating associates’ work, upward reviews shift the focus to leadership assessment, helping law firms build a culture of accountability, transparency, and continuous improvement.
Why Are Upward Reviews Important?
Law firms operate in high-stakes, high-pressure environments, where leadership quality directly impacts associate retention, morale, and productivity. However, many firms lack mechanisms for partners to receive constructive feedback from those they manage. Upward reviews bridge this gap by offering firms:
- A clearer understanding of leadership effectiveness – Helping partners recognize strengths and areas for improvement.
- Actionable insights for mentorship development – Encouraging partners to support associates’ career growth.
- Increased associate engagement and satisfaction – Giving associates a voice leads to higher job satisfaction.
- Improved retention rates – Firms that conduct upward reviews see lower turnover and stronger workplace culture.
How Upward Reviews Differ from Traditional Performance Reviews
Traditional performance reviews in law firms are top-down evaluations, where partners assess associates’ productivity and casework. While this provides valuable insights into associate performance, it overlooks leadership effectiveness—a critical factor in workplace satisfaction and retention.
In contrast, upward reviews create a two-way feedback system, where associates evaluate partners on leadership capabilities. This enables firms to identify and correct leadership blind spots, ultimately leading to better work environments.
How Upward Reviews Strengthen Partner & Associate Relationships
1. Encouraging Open Communication
Upward reviews create a structured space where associates can provide honest feedback without fear of repercussions. This helps partners understand how their leadership is perceived and identify ways to build stronger, trust-based relationships with their teams.
Key Areas of Evaluation:
- Approachability and communication style
- Support for associate career development
- Responsiveness to feedback and concerns
- Fairness in work distribution and case assignments
2. Helping Partners Become Better Mentors
A law firm’s strength is often measured by how well it develops its next generation of attorneys. Good mentorship is crucial, yet many partners may not realize the impact their guidance—or lack thereof—has on associate development.
Upward reviews allow firms to assess:
- Whether associates feel supported in their growth
- If partners provide meaningful feedback and career guidance
- How well mentorship efforts align with firm goals
3. Improving Workplace Morale & Engagement
When associates feel heard and valued, they are more engaged in their work. Firms that embrace upward reviews often see improved workplace culture, as partners become more aware of their impact on associate well-being.
According to a McKinsey & Company study, organizations that prioritize leadership feedback and improvement experience a 22% increase in employee engagement.
Best Practices for Implementing Upward Reviews in Law Firms
For upward reviews to be effective, firms must ensure they are confidential, structured, and action-oriented. Below are some key steps to successfully implement an upward review process:
- Create Anonymous Surveys: Ensure that associates feel comfortable sharing honest feedback without concerns of retaliation.
- Use Standardized Criteria: Develop clear, objective categories for evaluating leadership effectiveness.
- Encourage Constructive Feedback: Frame reviews as a way to help partners grow, rather than a tool for criticism.
- Analyze & Act on Results: Review data regularly and implement targeted leadership development initiatives.
- Follow Up with Associates: Demonstrate that their feedback is valued by updating them on leadership changes based on their input.
Conclusion
Strong leadership isn’t just about winning cases—it’s about supporting and developing the people within a firm. Upward reviews offer a valuable tool for ensuring that partners are not just effective legal practitioners, but also effective leaders.
By implementing a structured feedback system, law firms can enhance mentorship, strengthen relationships, and create a more engaged and satisfied workforce.
Want to improve leadership and retain top talent? Contact Survey Research Associates (SRA) today to build an upward review program tailored to your firm’s needs.
.png){kind=small}
