What separates high-performing law firms from those that simply get by? It's not just the quality of clients or the number of billable hours. More often, it's culture—and specifically, a culture rooted in ongoing, honest, and actionable feedback.
In many firms, feedback is limited to end-of-year reviews that feel performative rather than helpful. Associates rarely get clarity on their performance until something goes wrong. Partners, meanwhile, often receive no real feedback at all, despite holding key leadership roles.
But the legal landscape is evolving. The most successful firms today recognize that feedback isn't a formality—it's a competitive advantage.
A strong feedback culture leads to:
- More engaged and motivated attorneys
- Better leadership at every level
- Lower associate turnover
- Stronger client service through improved collaboration
At SRA, we've worked with firms across the country to help them shift from reactive, compliance-driven evaluations to proactive, development-focused feedback systems. The results speak for themselves: lower attrition, stronger morale, and measurable leadership growth.
If you're serious about building a firm that grows with its people—not despite them—this is where to start.
Here are five steps to building a culture of feedback that actually works.
Step 1: Define What Great Leadership Looks Like
Promoting great billers to leadership positions is common—but it often results in poor people management. Why? Because most firms never clearly define what leadership actually means.
Start by co-creating a leadership competency model tailored to your firm. Key traits might include:
- Communicates expectations clearly
- Provides regular, constructive feedback
- Supports diverse learning styles and work habits
- Fosters psychological safety and inclusion
Without a shared definition of leadership, feedback will always feel subjective.
Step 2: Implement Upward Reviews
Traditional reviews flow one way: top-down. But in a healthy culture, feedback flows in both directions.
Upward reviews give associates a safe, anonymous way to provide input about their managers. This isn’t about criticism—it’s about growth.
Fact: Firms that use upward reviews report a 33% improvement in perceived leadership effectiveness within a year (SRA client data).
Benefits include:
- Surfacing blind spots in partner behavior
- Strengthening associate-partner relationships
- Creating a feedback culture based on trust
Associates feel heard. Leaders get better. Everyone wins.
Step 3: Offer Coaching Based on Review Data
The data from upward reviews is only useful if it leads to action.
This is where coaching plays a critical role. Structured leadership coaching turns anonymous comments into personal development plans. It also:
- Builds confidence in new or struggling leaders
- Provides tools for inclusive team management
- Aligns partner behavior with firm values
One Am Law firm that implemented coaching post-upward reviews saw a 40% drop in voluntary associate departures within 9 months.
Step 4: Reward Leadership—Not Just Billables
If leadership isn’t recognized, it won’t be prioritized.
Most firms still promote based on origination and hours. But if you want leaders who develop others, you need to reward that work. Start by:
- Including leadership scores in annual evaluations
- Making feedback and mentorship part of promotion criteria
- Recognizing and celebrating inclusive leaders
“I knew what numbers I had to hit—but I never knew if I was being a good leader.” — Former associate at a Top 100 firm
Leadership development without reward is just lip service.
Step 5: Repeat the Cycle
Feedback is not a one-time initiative. It’s a cycle.
To keep your culture growing:
- Conduct upward reviews at least annually
- Offer real-time feedback channels (e.g., pulse surveys)
- Revisit leadership definitions and competencies as the firm evolves
- Measure outcomes and iterate
Firms with a continuous feedback loop are 3x more likely to retain top performers and 2x more likely to report client satisfaction gains.
Culture change isn’t a box to check. It’s a habit to build.
Final Thoughts: Great Cultures Don’t Happen by Accident
If your firm is struggling with engagement, leadership gaps, or uneven culture across teams—you’re not alone. Most law firms weren’t built with feedback in mind.
But that’s changing.
The firms that prioritize leadership development, open feedback, and accountability are winning the war for talent and client loyalty.
Your attorneys don’t want another policy. They want clarity. They want to grow. And they want to feel heard.
That starts with a feedback-driven culture.
Ready to Build a Culture of Feedback at Your Firm?
At SRA, we help law firms turn feedback into a strategic advantage. Through upward reviews, leadership coaching, and performance culture design, we help create environments where people and performance thrive together.
Visit https://www.srahq.com/ to learn how we can help your firm lead better.
.png){kind=small}
